Breaking the Silence

Much has been written on the unhelpful banalities that people often say when they are face-to-face with the newly bereaved. At a loss for words and knowing deep down that we cannot do or say anything to take the pain away, we find ourselves resorting to tired cliches that, more often than not, bring little comfort to the person in mourning:

They are in a better place.

Everything happens for a reason.”

It was their time.”

Life must go on.”

Such sentiments ring all the more hollow when a baby has been lost, whether it be through miscarriage, stillbirth, or infant death. When these tragedies strike, the following platitudes are frequently thrown into the mix:

They were too beautiful for this earth.”

God needed another angel.”

You can always have more children.”

I count myself fortunate that the closest people in my life have been thoughtful enough not to hurl such cliches at me following Leah’s death. And even when people’s condolences have been less than astute, I can recognize and appreciate their good intentions.

However, there is one general reaction that I have encountered that cuts me deeply. It is evident in the messages that aren’t returned, the phone calls that aren’t made, and the “How are you’s?” and “I’m sorry’s” that aren’t said.

The silence.

I get it. Humans are notoriously bad at confronting death and bereavement. It reminds us of all the things we’d rather not think about, like our own mortality, how little control we have over our lives, and the terrifying reality that none of us is immune to tragedy. Most of all, though, we know that there is nothing we can say to truly make things better for the bereaved, and for fear of saying the wrong thing and doing more harm than good, we opt to say nothing at all.


Image credit via WeKnowMemes

Several weeks after Leah’s death I attended a social function that I had been bracing myself for. I knew the day would be triggering because I had long assumed that my baby girl would accompany me (I even had a dress picked out for her to wear for the occasion), and on top of that I feared how the other attendees might react to me. Many of them had seen me very pregnant only a few weeks prior and knew about my loss. I wondered how these friends and acquaintances would handle my presence, and I was prepared for various possibilities. However, I wasn’t prepared for the deafening silence.

Suddenly people who had laughed with me and asked me questions about my pregnancy weeks before could not bring themselves to look me in the eye. It wasn’t until I took it upon myself to initiate conversations with them that anyone spoke to me, and even then the “How are you doing’s?” and “I’m sorry for your loss’s” never came. I have run into this situation repeatedly since then, and each time I am taken aback by the absurdity of pushing reality aside and acting “normal” to protect others from momentary discomfort.

So let’s be real. My daughter is dead. I’m not okay. You know I’m not okay. I assume that most loss mamas would agree that we don’t expect you to say all the right things to make us feel better; nobody can do that. In the same way, we don’t expect every social interaction to center around us and our losses. All we really want is some sort of acknowledgement. It can be as subtle as letting us know you’ve been thinking about us and asking us how we are.

Here’s the thing. Every loss mama I’ve encountered wants to talk about the child(ren) they lost. Indeed, we need to. In many cases of miscarriage, stillbirth, and infant death, the parents are the only ones who saw and touched their babies. In the case of early losses, there may be no tangible evidence aside from a positive pregnancy test that the baby existed at all. Often there are no shared memories or experiences to commiserate over with others, and the thought that our children will be forgotten by the world is nearly as heartbreaking as their daily absence from our families.

So don’t worry about saying the “right thing.” Instead, create space for us to talk about our losses. Open up the conversation by simply asking us how we are, and we’ll take it from there. Don’t be afraid to break the silence by saying our children’s names and asking us questions about them. Even if it brings the occasional tear to our eyes, knowing that someone else holds our children in their mind and heart makes all the difference in the world.